Best Long Slot Toaster: The Five Best Options for Toast Lovers

Best Long Slot Toaster: The Five Best Options for Toast Lovers

Updated on - . 13 min read

Imagine a morning where each slice of bread transforms into a warm, crispy delight, perfectly browned to your preference. That's the promise of a great long-slot toaster, the unsung hero of the kitchen that turns a mundane morning into a delectable start to the day. In this quest for the ultimate breakfast companion, we're not just looking for a toaster; we're seeking a reliable countertop ally that brings joy with the press of a lever. So, if you're ready to elevate your toast game and bask in the glow of perfectly browned bread, bagels, and more, join us as we delve into the world of long-slot toasters, where every detail from crunch to crumb is worth savoring.

🤝As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through our links, at ZERO additional cost to you.

5 Best Long-Slot Toasters

  1. Best Overall: KitchenAid Long-Slot Toaster
  2. Editor's Choice: Elite Gourmet Long-Slot Toaster (ECT-3100)
  3. Best for Modern Design: Mueller Ultra-Toast Long-Slot Toaster
  4. Best for Innovation: Dash Clear View Long-Slot Toaster
  5. Best Compact: Oster Long-Slot Toaster

1. Best Overall

KitchenAid Long-Slot Toaster

It strikes the perfect balance between aesthetic appeal and functionality. With its consistent performance, versatile slot size, and range of settings, it stands out as the most comprehensive package for most users.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Elegant Design: Aesthetic that enhances kitchen decor.
  • Consistent Performance: Evenly browns toast on both sides.
  • Versatile Slot Size: Accommodates various bread shapes and sizes.
  • Customizable Settings: Seven toast settings plus Bagel, Reheat, and "A Little Longer" options.
  • Self-Centering: Ensures even toasting for every slice.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Loud Beep: The end-of-cycle alert may be considered disruptive.

Why It Might Be Right for You

The KitchenAid Long-Slot Toaster is the epitome of form meeting function in a dance of culinary precision. It's for the aesthete with an eye for classic design and a palate for perfection. This toaster isn't just an appliance; it's a statement piece that whispers elegance while boasting modern functionality. If your mornings are a ritual of taste and style, and you're drawn to the harmony of vintage charm and contemporary features, this KitchenAid creation is crafted just for you. It's more than a toaster—it's an experience that complements the artistry of your kitchen.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I'm really happy with this toaster's long 39" cord since my outlet isn't close by. It feels sturdy and well-made, not cheap at all. Plus, my teenage son loves its cool, mid-century look. With just 5 temperature settings, finding the right one for different bread types is easy, and I appreciate that the control numbers are on the toaster itself – they won't wear off like my old one. Just a few days in, and it's been great.

2. Editor's Choice

Elite Gourmet Long-Slot Toaster (ECT-3100)

This toaster is selected for its exceptional value, offering a blend of necessary features and user-friendly design at a price that's hard to beat, making it a top pick for both quality and affordability.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Versatile Toasting: Fits bagels and English muffins with 1.5-inch-wide slots.
  • Even Browning: Delivers consistently even toasts.
  • Customizable: 6 toasting levels for your preferred browning.
  • Convenient Features: Includes a Reheat Function and a Cancel Button.
  • Unique Warming Rack: Retractable rack for warming various baked goods.
  • User-Friendly Design: Lightweight, with a removable crumb tray and cord storage.
  • Cost-Effective: Offers high value at a budget-friendly price.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Energetic Ejection: Toasts may pop out with too much vigor.
  • Limited Settings: Lacks self-centering guides and specific bagel settings.

Why It Might Be Right for You

For those who value a seamless blend of speed and functionality in their kitchen appliances, the Elite Gourmet Long-Slot Toaster steps up to the plate. It's not just about toasting bread; it's about starting your day with a sense of ease and satisfaction. With this toaster, you're not just preparing breakfast; you're setting the tone for the whole day ahead. So, if you're looking for a toaster that can keep up with your dynamic lifestyle and still serve up a slice of perfection, your search might just end here.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I switched from a pricey $300 toaster to this budget-friendly one and couldn't be happier. It toasts incredibly fast, even with thick slices of bread or bagels, which is a huge plus. Just a heads-up, though – you might want to keep the setting low, as anything past number two tends to burn the toast. It's a bit of trial and error at first, but once you find the sweet spot, it's perfect.

3. Best for Modern Design

Mueller Ultra-Toast Long-Slot Toaster

With its sleek design and advanced features like the futuristic-looking LCD panel, this toaster is ideal for those who prioritize kitchen aesthetics along with functionality.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Perfect Crust: Ensures the desired crunchiness in every toast.
  • Sleek Design: Modern look that saves countertop space.
  • Wide Slots: Accommodates thick bagels and artisan bread with ease.
  • Advanced Features: Includes Defrosting and Reheat functions with self-centering guides.
  • Intuitive LCD Panel: Futuristic design for setting adjustments.
  • Adjustable Browning: Six levels to get your toast just right.
  • Easy Cleaning: Comes with a removable crumb tray.

What to Keep in Mind

  • No Bagel Setting: Lacks a specialized function for bagels.
  • Default Reset: Settings revert to default after each use, requiring readjustment.

Why It Might Be Right for You

The Mueller Ultra-Toast Long-Slot Toaster is for the minimalist who doesn't compromise on functionality. Its sleek form factor belies a robust set of features that cater to the discerning toast aficionado. Whether it's the crunch of a perfectly browned artisan slice or the warm embrace of a reheated croissant, this toaster is all about precision. It's for the individual who steps into the kitchen and wants their appliances to not just work, but to work with an elegance that matches their own. If that's you, the Mueller Ultra-Toast is waiting to become the newest member of your culinary ensemble.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I'm absolutely thrilled with my new toaster; it's revolutionized my breakfasts and seriously upped my toast game. Not only does its sleek stainless steel design look amazing on my countertop, but it also delivers perfectly even toast every time. The wide slots are great for any bread type, and the defrost and reheat functions are super convenient. Plus, cleaning is a snap with the removable crumb tray, and the cool exterior and automatic shut-off add a nice safety touch. I wholeheartedly recommend it for anyone looking to elevate their toast experience.

4. Best for Innovation

Dash Clear View Long-Slot Toaster

The clear view window is a unique feature that allows users to watch their toast as it browns, which is perfect for those who love a bit of tech and innovation in their kitchen appliances.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Visual Monitoring: Glass window for watching your toast brown.
  • Feature-Rich: Defrost, Reheat, Bagel modes, and auto-shutoff included.
  • Adjustable Browning: Up to 7 levels for personalized toast.
  • Compact Design: Smart and space-efficient for any kitchen.
  • Easy to Clean: Removable glass panel and sliding crumb tray.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Single Slot: Limited to toasting two slices at a time.
  • Uneven Browning: May produce varying shades on each side of the bread.

Why It Might Be Right for You

The Dash Clear View Long-Slot Toaster is a match for the detail-oriented, the ones who take pleasure in the process as much as the result. With its see-through window, this toaster isn't just about the taste and texture—it's about the experience. It's for those who appreciate the art of toasting, the subtle changes in shade that signal the perfect crunch. If your morning ritual includes a moment of tranquility as you watch your bread achieve golden perfection, the Dash Clear View offers a front-row seat to the show. This isn't just a toaster; it's a window to a delightful start to your day.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

We've only had this toaster for five days, but it's already a hit, especially with my 12-year-old who lives for toast. He was skeptical at first, missing out on a fancy touchscreen model, but the window feature won him over. He's been using it non-stop, perfecting his toast shade, and even went through a whole loaf on day one. My 10-year-old loves the easy-to-clean glass, and while my older kids aren't as expressive, they're using it without complaints. I'm a fan too; it's simple to use, looks good on the counter, and fits a slice of sourdough bread without any slicing gymnastics.

5. Best Compact

Oster Long-Slot Toaster

For those with limited counter space who still want a full range of features, this toaster offers a compact design without compromising on the essentials like wide slots and multiple settings.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Versatile Size: Fits thick bagels and English muffins in a compact design.
  • Convenient Features: Bagel, Reheat, Defrost, and Cancel functions for ease of use.
  • Adjustable Toasting: Offers 1 to 7 darkness settings for personalized results.
  • Easy Cleaning: Dishwasher-safe crumb tray for simple maintenance.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Bagel Function: Not flawless in its bagel toasting performance.
  • Short Power Cord: May require an extension for optimal placement.

Why It Might Be Right for You

The Oster Long-Slot Toaster is for the pragmatist who cherishes simplicity paired with efficiency. It's for those who appreciate a toaster that can slide into any corner of the kitchen, yet stand out when it comes to performance. Whether it's the aroma of a freshly toasted bagel or the warmth of a just-right English muffin, this toaster is about getting the basics right every single time. If you're someone who values straightforward functionality without the fuss, the Oster Long-Slot Toaster could be your dependable morning companion.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I had to replace my old toaster after a peanut butter mishap, and after a brief stint with a less impressive model, I came back to this one. It's almost perfect right from the start, and I've heard it only gets better with time, like fine wine. It's sleek, efficient, and I love that I don't have to fish for my toast. All the heating elements light up, ensuring even toasting. Truly, it's a fantastic toaster that lives up to the hype.

How We Chose Our Top Picks

In selecting our top long-slot toaster picks, we've relied on a blend of methodical research and customer insights from sources like Amazon reviews to ensure expertise in our recommendations. We focused on reputable brands with a price below $100, balancing affordability with quality.

Our criteria included evaluating the smart features of each toaster for their practicality and user-friendliness. We assessed reliability through consistent performance and ease of use, ensuring the toasters deliver perfect results every time. We also considered the capacity of the slots to handle various bread types and the ease of cleaning, prioritizing toasters with removable crumb trays and low-maintenance designs.

This careful vetting process has led us to a selection that excels in functionality, design, and overall value, helping you choose the best toaster for your daily needs.

Why do you need a Long Slot Toaster Oven?

Everybody loves toasty bagels and muffins, but will most toasters offer the same quality results? Nobody has the time and money to afford a variety of toasters to ensure everything fits in. Do you even have the time or energy to plug in one toaster for a bagel and yet another for your long slice of bread?

To help you avoid these headaches, we have put together a list of long slot toasters that perfectly matches your style and needs. However, let's first learn what should be considered before purchasing any long-slot toaster.

For perfectly brown toasts, look into these details before buying a toaster.

Even Browning on Both sides

If you are spending money to buy a long-slot toaster oven, you should opt for a product that at least gives you even browning of the baked good, and that too on both sides. One of the major problems often found in toaster brands is that sometimes the edges of the bread or bagel get more toasted than the center, and you are left with burnt toast. Even if you get your desired result, the other side probably will be different. Therefore, before buying any new toaster, keep this point in mind because it can turn your toasty dreams into a nightmare of constantly looking and checking after your muffins while toasting.

Slot Capacity and Overall size of Toaster

Imagine you got your new long-slot toaster and could not fit your thicker slices like bagels or English muffins. These sorts of toasters are a big no. Long-slot toasters are usually built to accommodate long-baked goods like artisan bread and bagels, which your day-to-day simple toaster cannot fit.

There should be enough space in each slot for two pieces of toast or both sides of your bagel. There should also be room in the slot to slide in the bagel smoothly without applying any force. However, what usually happens is that the bagels get stuck in a regular toaster making it hard to take them out. Sometimes, the bagel gets stuck inside the toaster, making it difficult to scrape it off later. On the other hand, long slot toasters offer you spacious slots that warm up your toast, giving you the right texture and crust you crave.

Check for features that make it easy to toast

Make sure whatever long-slot toaster you buy comes with high-tech options like Defrosting, Reheating, cancel toasting button, and a bagel setting. These options help save your precious time and keep you up with this fast-paced life.

These smart long-slot toasters give you more control over your delicious toast and make it easier to operate. However, do not forget that every brand claiming to have a smart long-slot toaster is unreliable. Be sure to check if it lives up to the promise made by the manufacturer!

Several replica brands in the market make false promises of delivering the best yet fail at even the simplest.

We all love a clean toaster

Surely, no one likes it when their face is showered with bread crumbs when pulling the toaster out of the kitchen cabinet or leaving a trail of bread crumbs when dragging the toaster on the kitchen countertop. Good, modern long-slot toasters are now being designed in accordance to have easy-to-clean characteristics. So, do consider this point while opting for your toaster.

Last but not least - The price

The market has plenty of options available. There are cheap long-slot toasters out in the market and professional long-slot toasters too. If you are looking for a durable, user-friendly, smart, and evenly browning toaster, you need to look between the $30 to $100 price range.

Considering less than the $30 price will force you to compromise on hassle-free toasting, and going above that price could be overkill until or unless you pick it for some commercial purpose.

But if it is for day-to-day home usage, you will get your perfect toaster in this price bracket.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I fit a whole bread slice in the toaster?

Yes, our toasters have wide slots that can accommodate a full bread slice, so there's no need to cut your bread to make it fit.

Is it possible to toast bagels in this toaster?

Absolutely! Our toasters feature a bagel function that toasts bagels to perfection, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside.

How many toast slices can I make at once?

The number of toast slices you can make at once varies by model. We offer toasters that can handle multiple slices simultaneously, allowing you to prepare enough toast for the whole family.

Will my toast be toasted evenly on both sides?

Yes, our toasters use advanced technology to ensure your toast is evenly browned on both sides every time.

How does this compare to most toasters on the market?

Our toasters are designed to outperform most toasters, offering consistent results, long-lasting durability, and a suite of features that cater to all your toasting preferences.

What's the best setting to use to toast bread without burning it?

Our toasters come with a range of settings. For the best results without burning, start on a lower setting and adjust as needed to find your perfect level of toastiness.

What is special about a Smeg toaster?

Smeg toasters are popular because they come with various features that make them different from the competition. For example, many models include a defrost function, so you can easily toast frozen bread without having to wait for it to thaw first. They also come in various colors, so you're sure to match one with your kitchen decor. Plus, Smeg toasters are known for their durable construction, which means they'll last for years with regular use.

What Option of Long Slot Toasters is Best For You?

So, which toaster is right for you and your home? All of the options that we presented can be great options. Now it comes down to personal preference. Hopefully, this article has clarified what long-slot toaster you want in your home. If not, keep reading articles like these or doing your own research until you can find the perfect long-slot toaster for you and your family. When picking out appliances for your home, it's important to take your time with such an investment.

Thanks for reading!

Items reviewed:

  1. Best Overall: KitchenAid Long-Slot Toaster
  2. Editor's Choice: Elite Gourmet Long-Slot Toaster (ECT-3100)
  3. Best for Modern Design: Mueller Ultra-Toast Long-Slot Toaster
  4. Best for Innovation: Dash Clear View Long-Slot Toaster
  5. Best Compact: Oster Long-Slot Toaster

KitchenAid Long-Slot Toaster

It strikes the perfect balance between aesthetic appeal and functionality. With its consistent performance, versatile slot size, and range of settings, it stands out as the most comprehensive package for most users.

Check Price on Amazon

Please note that the reviews on this page have been edited for readability and clarity while maintaining the essence of the original content.

Further Reading

  • For detailed instructions on keeping your toaster in tip-top shape, check out this comprehensive guide on how to clean a toaster inside and out at LoveToKnow.