You've decided that you want to buy a retro toaster. That's a great decision! These toasters are not only stylish and retro-inspired, but they also make great additions to any kitchen. But before you run out and purchase the first one you see, you should consider a few things.
There are a lot of different retro toasters on the market, and it can be tough to figure out which one is right for you. That's why we've put together this list of things to consider before buying a retro toaster. With this guide, you'll be able to find the perfect toaster for your needs and kitchen, and in the end, you will get your best retro toaster.
🤝As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through our links, at ZERO additional cost to you.
6 Best Retro Toasters
- Best Overall: 1. BUYDEEM 4-Slice Retro Toaster
- Editor's Choice: Keenstone 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best Splurge: Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best on a Budget: Nostalgia 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best for Small Spaces: Crownful 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best for Simplicity: Frigidaire 2-Slice Retro Toaster
1. Best Overall
BUYDEEM 4-Slice Retro Toaster
This toaster stands out for its comprehensive features, including the True Bagel Toasting function and a stylish retro design. Its ability to toast four slices simultaneously and cater to various bread types makes it a top choice for versatility and convenience.
What We Love:
- True Bagel Toasting Function: Crispy cutting side, soft interior for perfect bagels.
- Vintage Style: Retro flair that enhances kitchen aesthetics.
- Versatile Toasting: Wide slots, adjustable browning for diverse bread types.
- Efficient and Convenient: Four-slice capacity with dual control panels.
- Space-Saving Design: Compact with neat cord storage.
What to Keep in Mind:
- Initial Setup: Requires empty toasting cycles at first for optimal performance.
Why It Might Be Right for You:
If you're looking for a toaster that effortlessly combines style with high functionality, the BUYDEEM 4-Slice Retro Toaster is your ideal match. Perfect for families or those who love hosting brunches, its four-slice capacity and unique bagel toasting feature ensure you can cater to various tastes and preferences with ease. Its retro charm adds a touch of elegance to your kitchen, making it not just an appliance, but a part of your home's personality.
Customer Review (source: Amazon)
I'm really happy with my new Mellow Yellow toaster. It's been fantastic for toasting everything from bread and English muffins to hotdog and bulkie rolls, all to the perfect level of doneness and faster than my old toaster. The push-up feature is a game-changer – no more fishing out toast with tongs! Plus, the 4-slice capacity makes breakfast for my family so much easier. It even matches my yellow kitchen perfectly. Definitely an excellent purchase for anyone considering it.
2. Editor's Choice
Keenstone 2-Slice Retro Toaster
The Keenstone toaster impresses with its balance of affordability, style, and functionality. Its high-quality stainless steel construction and versatile toasting options make it a standout choice, earning it the Editor's Choice recognition.
What We Love:
- Affordable Smeg Alternative: Stylish retro design at a more accessible price point.
- Quality Material: Made with high-quality 18/8 stainless steel, durable, non-toxic, and BPA-free.
- Versatile Toasting Features: Bagel, cancel, and defrost functions for a variety of toasting needs.
- Customizable Browning: Six shade settings to suit all preferences.
- Wide Slots: Accommodates thicker bread slices, bagels, and more.
What to Keep in Mind:
- Manual Monitoring Required: While offering various settings, attention may be needed to ensure your toast reaches the perfect level of doneness without overcooking.
Why It Might Be Right for You:
The Keenstone toaster is a testament to the fact that quality and affordability can go hand in hand. If you're seeking a reliable toaster that doesn't skimp on style or functionality but remains within a reasonable budget, this is the choice for you. Whether you're a student, a young professional, or simply someone who values smart spending, this toaster meets your needs without compromise.
Customer Review (source: Amazon)
I'm thrilled with my stylish red toaster. It's not only good-looking but also toasts perfectly with several options, including a setting for bagels. And the price was just right!
3. Best Splurge
Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster
The Smeg toaster is the epitome of luxury in kitchen appliances. Its iconic 50s retro style, combined with superior build quality and performance, makes it an excellent splurge for those who want both functionality and a design statement.
What We Love:
- 50s Retro Style: Aesthetic design in various colors to match any kitchen decor.
- Ease of Use: Simple functionality for quick and perfect toasting.
- Versatile Toasting Options: Accommodates different bread types and thicknesses.
- Customizable Settings: Six browning levels and three pre-set programs for personalized toasting.
What to Keep in Mind:
- Size Consideration: While stylish, its compact size might not be suitable for larger households or those who frequently toast larger quantities of bread at once.
Why It Might Be Right for You:
The Smeg toaster is for the discerning buyer who appreciates the finer things in life. Its classic 50s aesthetic is a conversation starter, while its robust build and consistent performance justify the investment. Ideal for those who see their kitchen as a reflection of their style, this toaster offers a blend of luxury and practicality, making every breakfast a sophisticated affair.
Customer Review (source: Amazon)
I got this toaster as a gift for my girlfriend, and she absolutely loves it. It's definitely worth the money, with nothing feeling cheap and the build quality holding up well. It toasts quickly and efficiently – I usually set it to 2, and it's more than enough. But remember, it's still just a toaster. If you're not into aesthetics or build quality, a simpler $20 toaster would do the job for toasted bread.
4. Best on a Budget
Nostalgia 2-Slice Retro Toaster
For those looking to economize without sacrificing style, the Nostalgia toaster is the ideal pick. It offers essential toasting functions and a range of color options, providing both efficiency and aesthetic appeal at a budget-friendly price.
What We Love:
- Colorful Retro Design: Available in a range of colors including aqua-blue, black, pink, red, turquoise, white, and yellow.
- Customizable Toasting: Lighted control buttons with bagel, defrost, and cancel options for personalized toasting.
- Convenient Cord Storage: Helps maintain a tidy kitchen space and enhances safety.
- Versatile Slot Size: Extra-wide slots suitable for bagels, thick bread slices, English muffins, and more.
- Adjustable Browning Levels: Five settings to achieve your preferred toast doneness.
What to Keep in Mind:
- Limited Capacity: With only two slots, it might not be the best choice for larger families or those who need to toast multiple items quickly.
Why It Might Be Right for You:
For those who want to brighten up their kitchen without breaking the bank, the Nostalgia toaster is a perfect choice. Its cheerful color options bring a fun vibe to your morning routine, while its essential features ensure you don't miss out on functionality. It's ideal for anyone starting out in their first apartment or for those who love a pop of color in their kitchen essentials.
Customer Review (source: Amazon
I decided to buy this aqua toaster after reading other reviews, and they were spot on. It's the first toaster I've owned that evenly toasts both sides of the bread without needing to flip it. The setting just below #4 gives me perfectly browned gluten-free toast every time. I highly recommend it. Plus, it's cool-looking – a nice bonus. Just like with people, looks aren't everything, but they sure help.
5. Best for Small Spaces
Crownful 2-Slice Retro Toaster
The Crownful toaster is perfect for compact kitchens, offering a sleek design and essential features in a space-saving form. Its adjustable browning and easy-to-clean components make it a practical choice for smaller setups.
What We Love:
- Elegant Stainless Steel Design: Durable, long-lasting finish that's easy to clean.
- Convenient Cord Storage: Neatly tucks away the power cord for a clutter-free countertop.
- Versatile Toasting Functions: Includes bagel, cancel, and defrost options for various toasting needs.
- Wide Slots: Accommodates a variety of bread sizes, including thick slices and bagels.
- Adjustable Browning: Six-level browning setting and a timer for personalized toast preferences.
What to Keep in Mind:
- Attention to Browning: With its wide range of settings, finding your perfect toast shade might require some experimentation.
Why It Might Be Right for You:
If your kitchen space is at a premium, but you don't want to compromise on style or function, the Crownful toaster is your go-to. Its compact design fits snugly in any corner, while its sleek look adds a modern touch. Perfect for studio apartments, dorm rooms, or minimalist kitchens, it ensures you enjoy your favorite toasted treats without cluttering your space.
Customer Review (source: Amazon)
I'm really fond of this toaster, especially how the red color complements my kitchen. I tried toasting regular bread on #6, and it came out just perfect, reminding me of the quality I used to get from a Sunbeam toaster years ago. It's well-made and feels sturdy. Plus, I registered it for a free 1-year warranty, so if there are any issues, they'll replace it. For the price, it's a fantastic little toaster.
6. Best for Simplicity
Frigidaire 2-Slice Retro Toaster
The Frigidaire toaster is ideal for those who value straightforward, no-fuss operation. Its user-friendly design, combined with reliable performance and safety certification, makes it a solid choice for everyday toasting needs.
What We Love:
- Extra-Wide Slots: Ideal for toasting bagels, thick bread slices, English muffins, and more.
- ETL Certified: Ensures superior quality and safety standards.
- Compact Design: Weighing only 4.39 pounds, it's easy to store and handle.
- Versatile Toasting Options: Bagel, cancel, and defrost functions to cater to different toasting needs.
- Adjustable Browning Levels: Five settings for achieving the perfect toast shade.
What to Keep in Mind:
- Browning Precision: While it offers multiple browning levels, achieving the exact desired toast shade might require some trial and error, especially for first-time users.
Why It Might Be Right for You:
The Frigidaire toaster is ideal for those who appreciate simplicity and efficiency in their kitchen appliances. Its straightforward functionality means you get perfect toast without any fuss, making it suitable for busy mornings or for those who prefer a no-nonsense approach in the kitchen. Reliable, easy to use, and safe, it's a solid choice for everyday use.
Customer Review (source: Amazon)
I don't usually write reviews, but this white toaster deserves an exception. Its look, design, and ergonomics are outstanding. It's simple in function, but the lever lifts the toast to an elevated height, making it easy to grab. Plus, there's a perfect spot for your thumb to hold it – it's these small things that really delight me and make the design perfect. And, of course, the toasts it makes are nice too! :D
How We Chose Our Top Picks
In selecting the best toasters, we focused on providing expert insights, even without personal use of each product. Our approach included:
- Extensive Research: We delved into detailed specifications and features of each toaster, comparing them against competitors.
- Customer Reviews: User feedback from platforms like Amazon played a crucial role, helping us understand real-world performance and durability.
- Key Features Analysis: We examined essential aspects like removable crumb trays, capacity for up to four slices, versatility for different bread types and bagel halves, and the efficiency of toasting slots and bagel functions.
- Design and Usability: The aesthetic appeal and user-friendliness of each retro style toaster were also crucial factors.
Frequently Asked Questions
How easy is it to clean the removable crumb tray in these toasters?
The removable crumb tray in these toasters is designed for convenience. It easily slides out, allowing you to quickly dispose of crumbs and keep your toaster clean with minimal effort.
Can I toast frozen bread directly in these toasters?
Absolutely! These toasters are equipped with a specific setting for frozen bread, ensuring you can enjoy perfectly toasted bread straight from the freezer.
What makes a two-slice toaster a good choice for smaller kitchens?
A two-slice toaster is ideal for smaller kitchens due to its compact size. It takes up minimal counter space while still offering efficient toasting capabilities for everyday use.
Are these toasters capable of toasting bagel halves evenly?
Yes, these toasters come with a special bagel function that perfectly toasts bagel halves, ensuring a crispy exterior and a soft, warm interior.
What sets a perfect retro toaster apart from modern designs?
The perfect retro toaster combines vintage aesthetics with modern functionality. It adds a touch of nostalgic charm to your kitchen while providing the latest toasting technology for the best results.
How does the retro style toaster blend in with contemporary kitchen designs?
A retro style toaster can add a unique and stylish element to contemporary kitchens. Its classic design and vibrant colors can complement modern appliances and decor, creating an interesting visual contrast.
How does a toaster oven differ from a traditional toaster?
A toaster oven is more versatile than a traditional toaster. It can perform various functions like baking, broiling, and toasting larger items, whereas a traditional toaster is primarily used for toasting bread, bagels, and similar items.
Can I toast frozen waffles in these toasters?
Yes, you can easily toast frozen waffles in these toasters. The wide toasting slots and adjustable settings ensure that frozen waffles are heated evenly and to your desired crispiness.
What is the benefit of having a toaster that can toast up to four slices?
A toaster that can handle up to four slices at once is great for families or when serving multiple people, offering efficiency and saving time during busy mornings.
How does a four-slice toaster enhance the toasting experience?
A four-slice toaster allows for more toasting capacity, making it ideal for larger households. It often comes with independent controls for each pair of slots, providing versatility in toasting preferences.
Items reviewed:
- Best Overall: 1. BUYDEEM 4-Slice Retro Toaster
- Editor's Choice: Keenstone 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best Splurge: Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best on a Budget: Nostalgia 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best for Small Spaces: Crownful 2-Slice Retro Toaster
- Best for Simplicity: Frigidaire 2-Slice Retro Toaster
Best Overall: BUYDEEM 4-Slice Retro Toaster
This toaster stands out for its comprehensive features, including the True Bagel Toasting function and a stylish retro design. Its ability to toast four slices simultaneously and cater to various bread types makes it a top choice for versatility and convenience.
Please note that the reviews on this page have been edited for readability and clarity while maintaining the essence of the original content.
Further Reading
- For an in-depth look at the advantages of using a toaster in your daily routine, check out this informative article on Redmond Home: What Are the Benefits of Using a Toaster.
