Best Toaster Under $50: 6 Budget-Friendly, but Amazing Options

Best Toaster Under $50: 6 Budget-Friendly, but Amazing Options

Updated on - . 16 min read

Kickstart your mornings with a crispy crunch from a toaster that doesn't crunch your budget. We've scoured the shelves for budget toasters that punch way above their weight, offering you the golden glow of perfect toast without a hefty price tag. Among our top picks, we proudly feature some of the best 2 slice toasters under $50, combining affordability with quality. Say goodbye to half-baked features and hello to affordable excellence. Ready to meet your match? Let's dive into our selection and find the toaster that's just right for you!

🤝As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through our links, at ZERO additional cost to you.

6 Best Toasters Under $50

  1. Best Overall: BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster
  2. Editor's Choice: Cuisinart Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster
  3. Best Splurge: Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster
  4. Best on a Budget: iSiLER 2 Slice Toaster
  5. Best for Small Spaces: Hamilton Beach Toaster Extra Wide Slots
  6. Best for Design-Conscious: BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

1. Best Overall

BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster

This toaster offers a great blend of features, capacity, and efficiency with its four wide slots, versatile settings including bagel, frozen, and cancel functions, and dual control panels. Its 850-watt heating element suitable for 220-volt systems makes it a robust choice for various households.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Even Toasting: Delivers perfectly even toast, matching your desired shade.
  • Versatile Slot Size: Accommodates various bread types, including thick slices like Texas Toast and English muffins.
  • Convenient Features: Includes a lift lever for small items, shade selector, and easy-to-clean crumb tray.
  • Modern Design: Sleek look with three modes (toast, bagel, frozen) and a cancel option for added control.
  • Dual Control Panels: Operate two slots independently for efficiency.
  • Powerful: 850-watt heating element, suitable for 220-volt systems.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Size: May occupy significant counter space due to its 4-slice capacity.

Why It Might Be Right for You

If you're seeking a powerhouse in your kitchen that can handle the breakfast needs of a busy family or someone who loves entertaining, the BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster is your match. It's perfect for those who need a versatile toaster with the capacity to toast various breads and pastries to perfection. With its dual independent control panels, this toaster is a multitasker's dream, allowing you to cater to different toasting preferences simultaneously. It's our pick for the best overall due to its robust features and versatile functionality.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

This is my third toaster in a year, and finally, I've found one that toasts evenly without having to flip the bread halfway through! It's a bit on the large side, but that's a small trade-off for perfectly toasted bread every time. Really happy with this purchase.

2. Editor's Choice

Cuisinart Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster

This toaster balances functionality with a sleek design, offering wide slots, customizable settings with a 6-setting shade dial, and additional functions like reheat, defrost, and bagel with LED indicators. Its high-lift carriage and classic finish make it the editor's choice for style and function.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Compact and Functional: Ideal for kitchens with limited counter space, offering essential toasting functions.
  • Extra-Wide Slots: Accommodates a range of bread sizes, from thin waffles to thick artisanal bread.
  • Customizable Settings: Features a 6-setting shade dial for precise toasting control.
  • Versatile Functions: Includes reheat, defrost, and bagel options with LED indicators.
  • Safe Retrieval: Extra-lift carriage lever for easy and safe toast removal.
  • Sleek Design: Classic brushed stainless steel finish adds elegance to any kitchen décor.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Warranty Consideration: Comes with a limited 3-year warranty, important to consider for long-term use.

Why It Might Be Right for You

For the style-savvy toast lover, the Cuisinart Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster with its timeless design will not only enhance your countertop but also deliver on performance. It's suited for those who don't want to compromise on aesthetics while enjoying the practicality of a high-lift lever and diverse shade settings. If your mornings call for a touch of elegance with your perfectly browned toast, this is the editor's choice for you.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I replaced my old toaster with the same model after 15 years, and it's still going strong. It fits perfectly in my kitchen, and while the crumb tray could be better, it's a small price to pay for a toaster that handles everything from toast to waffles with ease.

3. Best Splurge

Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster

Priced slightly over $50, the Mueller UltraToast stands out with its long slot chambers, quick toasting time, and advanced features such as roll attachments and roasting time electronics. It's ideal for those willing to invest a bit more for enhanced performance and capacity.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Long Slot Chambers: Ideal for families, toasting up to 4 regular or 2 long slices simultaneously.
  • Versatile Browning: Offers six levels of browning for personalized toast preferences.
  • Efficient Toasting: Quick 2-minute toasting at medium heat with consistent browning.
  • Extra Features: Includes defrost and reheat functions, and a spacious roll attachment.
  • Sturdy Build: Solid construction without sharp edges.
  • Intelligent Technology: Equipped with a temperature sensor and roasting time electronics for even toasting.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Price: Slightly over the $50 budget.

Why It Might Be Right for You

When only the best will do, and you're willing to indulge a little, the Mueller UltraToast stands ready to exceed expectations. Its premium build and quick toasting time make it ideal for those who value speed and performance in their culinary tools. If your kitchen is the heart of your home and you take pride in having top-tier appliances, this splurge is justified with every perfectly toasted slice.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I'm thrilled with my new toaster that's revolutionized my breakfasts, turning my toast into a culinary masterpiece! It's not just functional, but also a sleek addition to my kitchen. It toasts everything evenly, from bread to muffins, and the defrost and reheat functions are total lifesavers. Plus, cleaning is so easy with the crumb tray. This is hands-down the best toaster purchase I've made!

4. Best on a Budget

iSiLER 2 Slice Toaster

Offering seven shades of toasting and three toasting modes at a lower price point, the iSiLER 2-slice toaster is energy-efficient with 750W power and includes a crumb tray and cleaning brush, making it the best option for those looking to save without sacrificing quality.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • High Power Efficiency: 750W power for quick toasting, saving energy while delivering optimal results.
  • Wide Slot Design: Accommodates thick slices of bread, muffins, and waffles, measuring 5.4x1.3 inches each.
  • Versatile Toasting Modes: Features reheat, defrost, and cancel modes with LED indicators for ease of use.
  • Adjustable Browning: Offers seven browning levels for personalized toast crispness.
  • Easy to Clean: Includes a removable crumb tray and a convenient cleaning brush.
  • Safety First: Made with safe, fast-heated stainless steel and PP body, UL certified.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Compact Size: A 2-slice toaster, may not be suitable for larger families or heavy use.

Why It Might Be Right for You

The iSiLER 2 Slice Toaster is the quintessential choice for the practical and budget-conscious. If you're starting out on your own or simply prefer the minimalistic approach to your kitchen gadgets, this toaster offers straightforward functionality without breaking the bank. With its energy efficiency and easy-to-use features, it’s the smart pick for those who want simplicity and economy.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I got this toaster for our new kitchen and it's not only adorable but easy to use with straightforward temperature control. It mostly toasts well, though not always perfectly even, but that's a minor issue for a toaster that's so good for the price.

5. Best for Small Spaces

Hamilton Beach Toaster Extra Wide Slots

With its compact size and smart features like adjustable shade selector and toast boost, this 2-slice toaster is perfect for those with limited counter space who still want the convenience of toasting thick slices and bagels.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Adjustable Shade Selector: Tailor your toasting for perfect bagels and bread every time.
  • Toast Boost Feature: Elevates toast for easy, safe retrieval without utensils.
  • Versatile Settings: Includes a defrost setting and accommodates thick slices with its extra-wide slots.
  • Convenient Design: Features a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning.
  • Budget-Friendly: Offers high value just slightly above the $50 budget.
  • Seven Toast Shades: Customize your toast level with a wide range of options.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Size: Only a 2-slice capacity, may require multiple batches for larger families.

Why It Might Be Right for You

In a snug kitchen, the Hamilton Beach Toaster shines as the space-saving champion. This toaster is a godsend for apartment dwellers or minimalists who prefer not to have their counters crowded. With its wide slots and smart features, it proves that small size does not mean sacrificing the pleasure of a warm, toasted bagel or slice of bread in the morning.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I'm back to a Hamilton Beach toaster, this time a 2-slice model, and I couldn't be happier. It does exactly what it's supposed to—toast—and does it well. After a failed experiment with a fancier brand, it's refreshing to have a no-frills, reliable toaster that, thanks to a little DIY, doesn't beep anymore. It may not be the fanciest with more plastic than metal, but it's definitely a keeper.

6. Best for Design-Conscious

BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

This toaster's sleek design and efficient 850-watt toasting capability make it a good match for those who prioritize kitchen aesthetics along with functionality, offering specialized functions for bagels and frozen items with a clean and modern look.

Check Price on Amazon

What We Love

  • Extra-Wide Slots: Ideal for various types of bread, including large bagels and English muffins.
  • Efficient Toasting: 850-watt power for fast and even toasting.
  • Versatile Functions: Offers special settings for bagels, frozen items, and a cancel option for flexibility.
  • Convenient Lift Lever: Ensures safe retrieval of toast without the need for utensils.
  • Easy Cleaning: Features a slide-out crumb tray to keep the counter clean.
  • Sleek Design: A stylish addition that complements any kitchen décor.

What to Keep in Mind

  • Crumb Tray Maintenance: Regular emptying of the crumb tray is needed for optimal performance.

Why It Might Be Right for You

For the aficionado of sleek kitchen appliances, the BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster is a blend of style and substance. It's particularly suited for those who appreciate the combination of a clean, modern aesthetic with the practicality of a high-performing toaster. If your morning toast is a ritual that marries form with function, this toaster's design and features make it an attractive, everyday luxury.

Customer Review (source: Amazon)

I've been using this toaster with the big slots for months, perfect for my bread and bagels. The cancel button is a lifesaver, and it's a breeze to clean. Definitely recommend it to all toast lovers!

How We Chose Our Top Picks

Our commitment to expertise in product evaluation is unwavering, even when direct experience with every item is not possible. To compile our top picks, we've undertaken a rigorous process of research, assessing a wide array of factors that contribute to the overall quality of the products. We've delved into user feedback and sifted through scores of customer reviews on platforms like Amazon to gauge real-world performance, longevity, and user-friendliness.

Beyond customer testimonials, we've scrutinized the specifications and features of each product, comparing them meticulously with their competitors. This comparative analysis is crucial, as it allows us to discern the unique value each product offers. We consider not just the immediate appeal of a product but its place in the broader market landscape, ensuring that our recommendations stand up not only to scrutiny but also to the test of time and use.

In evaluating these products, we also draw upon our deep understanding of industry standards and trends. By keeping abreast of the latest advancements and staying informed about recalls, manufacturing updates, and company reputations, we ensure that our selections are not only the best of what's currently available but also products from companies that stand behind their offerings.

Our top picks are the result of this comprehensive approach, where we balance empirical data with nuanced insights, aiming to provide you with a trusted guide to the best products on the market. Whether you're in search of the latest features, the best value, or the highest quality construction, our recommendations are designed to help you make an informed choice that aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

What did we look for in a toaster?

Does it accommodate large slices and toast bread evenly?

We sought toasters with slots that could accommodate slices of all sizes and shapes. We also wanted to know that the bread was placed fully inside the slot, with the bread being completely covered and untoasted. We analyzed whether the machines toast each side of bread equally and produced predictable variations in the light or dark toast options.

We also checked if toasters came with specific bagel settings. However, we didn't instantly disqualify models without these specifications.

Does the toaster have a good design?

A toaster with a good design is well-constructed and easy to operate. It should have an even heat distribution so that the bread is toasted evenly on all sides. The toaster should also be easy to clean, with removable parts that can be washed in the dishwasher.

Does it allow defrosting frozen items without burning them?

Today, many toasters feature an option to defrost, which is perfect for frozen waffles, bread, and breakfast treats; however, it's usually an uncooked waffle that's toasty on the outside but cold inside or defrosted but very watery. The aim is to find an appliance that can effectively defrost.

Is the toaster too big?

The kitchen counter is still valuable real property, even if you're not in a tiny space. With this in mind, we chose toasters that appeared carefully designed and balanced.

Are the settings easy to operate?

User-friendliness was a major concern for us. While we love the options available, we dislike design chaos. When we looked at each toaster, we assessed whether the toaster's control was functional and complete. We also assessed whether the interface appeared easy to understand (good) or required a careful review of the instruction manual (bad).

Do the customers love it?

It is important that we choose toasters to recommend that customers already love because those are the ones that are going to be the most successful. If a customer is unhappy with their purchase, the toaster will only end up in the landfill shortly after. Plus, it's a waste of money. We want to make sure that customers are happy with their purchase, and recommending a product that people are not going to like is not going to help us achieve that goal.

Buyer's Guide

There is no need for a commercially-produced toaster to get evenly toasty bread. Low-cost appliances, like coffee makers as well as toasters, are also a great choice for people with low incomes. However, a toaster for less than $50 is sufficient for your needs. To ensure you get the highest quality at that cost, you must consider the following factors to take into consideration. Learn more about them in our buyer's guide that follows.


We've seen kitchen appliances that remain strong and durable for a long time. Toasters less than $50 are extremely durable if the ones you buy are constructed from high-quality materials. The stainless steel used in kitchen appliances can outlast plastic if used properly and properly maintained.

Before buying a toaster for less than $50, look at the components. Do they break easily? Do they withstand the rigors of frequent use? In addition, you should always opt for reputable brands.

Features Like Removable Crumb Tray

If you don't understand what to do in order to defrost your bread correctly? Wouldn't your toaster, less than $50 be able to toast and defrost it properly for you? This, along with other options like bagels as well as automatic shut-off and cancel settings, are some of the features to look to find when looking for a toaster that costs less than $50. These may be expensive; however, they will simplify your life.

Easy to clean

A dirty and unsanitary toaster. Even if cleaning is difficult, it may be a real hassle. Make sure that the toaster priced under $50 that you're about to buy won't cause anxiety when it's time to be scrubbed. We suggest you look for one that has removable crumb trays, parts, and even a dishwasher.


The exterior used in toasters' exteriors is more focused on aesthetics than any other aspect. Our tests observed that the quality of the toast was not damaged in any way.

  • Toasters made of plastic: Generally, plastic toasters tend to be more affordable than steel, but they're not always the most attractive.
  • Toasters made of metal: Metal toasters usually are stainless or brushed steel. They can be paired with other kitchen appliances.

Toaster's Design

When choosing a toaster to use, consider the amount of toast you usually create at once and the size of bread you prefer to toast.

  • Toasters with four slices: If more than two people are trying to cook breakfast simultaneously, the four-slice toaster is likely to be the best option.
  • Toasters with two slices: If counter space is a problem, you might prefer two-slice toasters.
  • Toasters with long slots: Long-slot toasters are gaining popularity due to the popularity of more traditional bread. Consider long slots if you are a fan of the artisanal bread of sourdough and other varieties. It's unlikely that you'll be able to fit a full slice in a standard toaster without cutting the bread in half.
  • Toasters with wide slots: Look out for toasters that have wide slots. They make toasting bagels or more substantial slices of bread a lot easy and hassle-free.


As well Toast your bread until it's to your preferred shade and degree of doneness; search for a toaster with the most suitable settings for you.

For instance, the bagel setting typically toasts only the interior of a bagel. It also warms the outside, so you don't have to fret about a dry or sour bite.

Defrost settings are great for frozen waffles and bread and will generally prolong the toasting process to ensure that you'll get the same results as you would have if the bread or waffles were fresh.

Reheat settings generally toast bread or other ingredients for a brief time, which is ideal for toasting a pastry in a toaster or adding a little color.

Additional Features

While not all toasters include extra features, some desirable features are worth looking for when choosing the right toaster.

  • The touchscreen user interface is simple to use and read with a stylish design and typically greater toasting choices.
  • The glass windows let you observe your toaster while it's toasting to decrease the chance of burned toast.
  • A high-lift or motorized lever helps solve the problem of stuck toast and is difficult to remove from the slot in the toaster, and it also eliminates the manual effort of pushing the lever down.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a toaster oven and regular toasters?

A toaster oven is a versatile kitchen appliance that functions as both a mini-oven and a toaster, suitable for baking, broiling, and toasting larger items that wouldn't fit in regular toasters.

How can I prevent my bread from being underdone toast?

To avoid underdone toast, ensure that you're using the correct settings for your bread type and that your toaster's browning controls are properly adjusted for your desired level of doneness.

Are Cuisinart toasters capable of toasting artisan bread?

Cuisinart toasters are designed with wide slots and customizable settings to handle a variety of breads, ensuring even toasting from the thinnest slices to thick artisan breads. A popular Cusinart toaster is the 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster.

Can I use toaster ovens to make meals other than toast?

Absolutely, toaster ovens are excellent for a range of quick meals, not just for toasting bread. They're ideal for anyone looking to bake, broil, or heat up food conveniently without using a full-sized oven.

What are the benefits of a two slice toaster for smaller households?

A two slice toaster is ideal for smaller households or individuals, offering quick and efficient toasting without taking up too much counter space.

How do frozen bread settings on a toaster work?

Frozen bread settings are designed to defrost and then toast the bread in one cycle, ensuring you get warm, crispy toast from bread straight out of the freezer.

Where should toaster be placed in kitchen?

The placement of a toaster in the kitchen should consider both convenience and safety. Ideally, it should be placed on a flat, stable surface with ample clearance from any overhead cabinets. This is to avoid heat damage to any cabinetry or risk of fire. It's also important to keep the toaster away from wet areas like the sink to prevent electrical hazards. Ensure there's enough space around the toaster for heat dissipation and easy access for placing and removing bread.

What is the difference between cheap and expensive toasters?

The primary differences between cheap and expensive toasters often lie in build quality, features, and longevity.

  • Build Quality: Expensive toasters are generally made with higher-quality materials, which can offer better heat resistance and durability.
  • Features: Higher-priced toasters may offer more advanced features like wider slots for different bread types, precise browning controls, special functions for bagels, defrosting, reheating, and even smart features like toasting progress indicators.
  • Consistency and Performance: Expensive toasters tend to provide more consistent browning and can handle a wider variety of bread types effectively.
  • Design and Aesthetics: Often, more expensive toasters also offer more sophisticated designs and finishes, which can be a consideration for those matching kitchen aesthetics.
  • Longevity: Generally, you might find that more expensive toasters last longer due to better construction and component quality.

Final Remarks

Now that we've reviewed the best toasters under $50, we can tell you there really is no "best" toaster. Each toaster has unique strengths and weaknesses, which we've outlined in the individual reviews.

In our opinion, the best toaster under $50 is the Black + Decker. It has a sleek, elegant design that makes it the perfect addition to any kitchen. It is also versatile, with a bagel and frozen setting. The Black + Decker is also easy to use, with a lever to control the toasting process. This toaster is reliable, effective, and affordable, making it one of the best under $50. Which one is your favorite?

Items reviewed:

  1. Best Overall: BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster
  2. Editor's Choice: Cuisinart Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster
  3. Best Splurge: Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster
  4. Best on a Budget: iSiLER 2 Slice Toaster
  5. Best for Small Spaces: Hamilton Beach Toaster Extra Wide Slots
  6. Best for Design-Conscious: BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

Best Overall: BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster

This toaster offers a great blend of features, capacity, and efficiency with its four wide slots, versatile settings including bagel, frozen, and cancel functions, and dual control panels. Its 850-watt heating element suitable for 220-volt systems makes it a robust choice for various households.

Check Price on Amazon

Please note that the reviews on this page have been edited for readability and clarity while maintaining the essence of the original content.

Further Reading

  • Discover the versatility of your kitchen toaster with these innovative ideas from Buydeem's guide, showcasing things you can make with your toaster beyond just bread. Visit Buydeem’s Toaster Recipes for some culinary inspiration.