Best Toaster Under $50: 6 Budget-Friendly, but Amazing Options

Best Toaster Under $50: 6 Budget-Friendly, but Amazing Options

15 min read

Toasters are the most common home appliances that you find in your kitchen. You need a toaster in your kitchen because that is the easiest way to make toast. It is also the basic requirement for people who love to eat toast with their breakfast.

There are a lot of toasters available in the market. You will find tons of cheap toasters as well as high-end toasters. Finding the best toaster is not an easy task. But the task becomes a little easier if we only set a budget.

Many budget toasters offer unique features and innovative designs to meet your needs. This blog will help you choose the best toasters under $50 available on the market.

It's possible that you won't be able to toast eight slices at once using these portable toasters, but you will have evenly toasted bread. They'll give you the convenience and dependability you desire and guarantee you crisp toast within minutes.

Even if you're on a tight budget, it is still possible to find the top toasters that will help you get through your day effortlessly. We've gone through the countless toasters on the market and have put together six top toasters for under $50. Check out our reviews below.

Difference Between a Toaster and a Toaster Oven

A toaster is a small appliance that uses heat to toast bread, while a toaster oven is a larger appliance that can be used for baking, roasting, and toasting. Toasters typically have two or four slots for bread, while toaster ovens have a larger baking chamber. Toaster ovens also typically have a timer and temperature control, while toasters typically do not.

Toasters and toaster ovens may sound similar, but they serve different purposes. A toaster is designed to toast bread quickly, while a toaster oven can be used for baking and reheating food.

Toasters typically have narrower slots that accommodate one or two pieces of bread, while toaster ovens have wider slots and can accommodate larger items like pizzas or casseroles. Toasters also have shorter cooking times than toaster ovens, so they're better suited for quick, everyday tasks.

6 Best Toasters Under $50

There are a lot of great toasters out there, but if you're looking for the best toaster under $50, we've got you covered. Our top pick is the Black+Decker 4-Slice Toaster Oven, which has a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup, a bagel setting for perfectly toasted bread, and a frozen bread setting for those mornings when you forgot to take the bread out of the freezer.

It also has a frozen waffle setting, so you can have breakfast ready in no time. Suppose you're looking for a budget-friendly option. In that case, we recommend the Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster, which covers all the basics, including toast, bagels, English muffins, and frozen bread. It also has an extra-wide slot for thicker slices of bread and a removable crumb tray for easy cleanup.

How We Have Selected the Best Toasters Under $50

It can be hard to know which toaster is the best for your needs. You might not have the time or knowledge to research all of the different options yourself.

With so many different types, brands, and features of toasters on the market, it's no wonder people find it hard to decide which one is right for them. It can take hours of research to figure out which one has the features you need and which one will last.

Our editors have worked hard for you and found the best toasters based on their quality, durability, and customer feedback. We only recommend products that we would use in our own homes.

1. BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster

Customers are raving about this toaster. The toasted bread is evenly in the exact color people wanted, regardless of the setting.

The Black+Decker 4-Slice Toaster is a great addition to any kitchen. This toaster features four wide slots that can accommodate a variety of bread, bagels, and pastries.

The extra-lift lever ensures that smaller items won't get stuck, and the shade selector allows you to choose your desired level of toastiness. The Black+Decker toaster also has a crumb tray that slides out for easy cleaning.

This toaster is sleek with a modern design. It has three modes, toast, bagel, and frozen, which will toast bread precisely. A cancel option also allows you to stop the cycle at any time.

It has extra-wide slots to toast thicker bread like Texas Toast or English muffins. The cord storage helps keep your kitchen countertops clean and clutter-free. With an 850-watt heating element, this toaster can be used in countries that use 220 volts.

What We like:

  • Bread is toasted evenly and in the right shade for the dark setting.
  • Four slices of bread
  • Browning adjustment knob

2. Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster

Families with 3-4 members need a toaster with more power. The Müller UltraToast, with its long slot chambers, can toast up to 2 long slices or four regular slices of bread simultaneously.

There are six levels of browning available on the toaster. Even though there is no bagel function, this is almost overcome by the attachment for long buns, which can hold up to three buns.

You can also use sliced rolls in the toaster. However, XXL sandwich slices will not fit. When toasted, these will protrude slightly from your chambers and remain pale at their top edges.

The toaster is sturdy and does not have sharp edges. The toaster does not have a lift function.

The best 4-slice toaster, the double slot, is excellent toasting results and short toasting times.

The Mueller SuperToast takes just 2 minutes to toast at medium heat. The toaster's temperature sensor and built-in roasting time electronics ensure consistent browning even after multiple roasting cycles. This is a great price for the performance.

What We Like:

  • Functions for defrosting and reheating
  • Roll attachments with lots of space
  • Long-slot toaster
  • Low roasting time and roasting time electronics

3. Hamilton Beach Toaster Extra Wide Slots

The toaster from Hamilton has an adjustable shade selector that lets you perfectly toast your bagels batch after batch. And if you're worried about making a mess, don't be—the crumb tray on this 2-slice toaster is easy to remove and clean.

The toast boost feature on this toaster will help lift your toast up a little higher when it's done, so you can easily remove it without using a fork or other utensil. That way, you can enjoy your English muffin without worrying about burnt toast.

The 2-slice toaster has a defrost setting that will thaw them before toasting. Plus, the extra-wide slots make it easy to toast thick slices of bread, and the cancel button lets you stop the toasting cycle at any time. So, treat yourself to a delicious breakfast - your perfect toaster is waiting!

What We Like:

  • 4-Slice is about $5 over the $50 budget.
  • High-lift toast boost
  • Adjustable browning knob
  • Frozen bread settings

4. iSiLER 2 Slice Toaster

The iSiLER 2-slice toaster has a high power of 750W and safe edible 430 stainless for slots and PP body. This toaster can prevent scalding. It also features a bright yellow color that brings joy to the day.

It has two slots. Each slot measures 5.4x1.3 inches and can hold thick slices of various bread, muffins, and waffles.

The device has three toasting modes, including reheat, defrost and cancel. LED indicators provide a visual indicator to help you monitor your toasting progress. Defrost or reheat modes prevent over-browning and burning of bread or other foods. The cancel button, however, allows for a quick shutdown. Seven different browning levels can be used to create crispy, delicious bread.

This 2-slice compact plastic toaster has a crumb tray. To clean your toaster, simply slide the crumb tray out. The product comes with a 3.6-foot extension cord. It is convenient to store the cord at the bottom of your toaster. A cleaning brush is also included.

What We Like:

  • Excellent toaster with no crumb issues.
  • Seven shades for toasting bread
  • It is easy to clean and use.

5. Cuisinart Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster

If you're looking for a toaster that can do it all, then this compact toaster is the perfect choice for your kitchen countertop. This two-slice toaster can easily accommodate bagels and toast and even has a preheat, defrost and cancel option. With its sturdy construction and sleek design, this toaster will be a welcome addition to any kitchen. And thanks to its compact size, it won't take up much valuable counter space.

Its extra-wide toasting slots accommodate everything from thin waffles to thick artisanal bread, while the 6-setting shade dial lets you customize your toast to perfection. For even more versatility, the reheat, defrost, and bagel buttons come with LED indicators, so you can quickly and easily select the right setting every time. Plus, the high-lift carriage makes it easy to retrieve your toast without burning your fingers. With its classic brushed stainless steel finish, the Cuisinart 2-Slice Toaster is a welcome addition to any kitchen.

What We Like:

  • Extra-lift boost lever
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Defrost and reheat options

6. BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

The 2-slice Black+Decker toaster is ideal for getting started in the morning with a quick and easy breakfast. You can store all kinds of toast in the extra-large slots.

The toaster has three functions, including cancel, freeze, or bagel. The lever lifts the toast, so you can reach it safely. The counter is kept clean by the drop-down crumb tray. This keeps your kitchen fresh and clean.

This crumb tray allows you to remove crumbs before they start to burn. To get the best performance, you must empty the tray frequently.

Fast toasting makes your breakfast more delicious and quicker with the 850-watt Black+Decker 2-slice oven.

The Black & Decker 2-Slice Toaster brings simplicity and sophistication to your kitchen. It has six timed shade settings and special functions for bagels and frozen items, so you can enjoy a fresh slice at the perfect level of toastiness every time. Plus, the extra-wide slots fit oversized bread, bagels, or English muffins, while an extra lift lever makes it easy to retrieve your toast.

What We Like:

  • Extra Wide Slots
  • It is easy to clean.
  • Level browning is ideal.
  • Plenty of space to hold a large bagel.

What can a toaster oven under $50 do?

The toaster under $50 is one that can accommodate thick bagels, has a toasting cycle that is long enough to get a good toast on thick slices, and has a bagel setting. It should also have a defrost setting for frozen bread and a slide-out crumb tray. Other nice features include a high lift lever for getting smaller items out of the toaster without burning yourself and a low price.

Some toasters also come with an extra wide slot for thicker pieces of bread, but this is not essential. When it comes to making perfect toast, the key is in the thickness of the bread. If you are using sourdough or other thick bread, you will want a toaster that can accommodate it.

The best toasters will have a longer toasting cycle so that the bread has time to get evenly browned. They will also have a bagel setting, allowing you to toast the inside without burning the outside. When choosing a toaster, you should also consider how much counter space you have.

If you don't have much room, you might want one with a slide-out crumb tray to easily clean it out. Some toasters also come with an extra wide slot for thicker pieces of bread, but this is not essential. In general, the best toasters are those that can accommodate different types of bread and have adjustable settings to get the perfect toast.

What did we look for in a toaster?

Does it accommodate large slices and toast bread evenly?

We sought toasters with slots that could accommodate slices of all sizes and shapes. We also wanted to know that the bread was placed fully inside the slot, with the bread being completely covered and untoasted. We analyzed whether the machines toast each side of bread equally and produced predictable variations in the light or dark toast options.

We also checked if toasters came with specific bagel settings. However, we didn't instantly disqualify models without these specifications.

Does the toaster have a good design?

A toaster with a good design is well-constructed and easy to operate. It should have an even heat distribution so that the bread is toasted evenly on all sides. The toaster should also be easy to clean, with removable parts that can be washed in the dishwasher.

Does it allow defrosting frozen items without burning them?

Today, many toasters feature an option to defrost, which is perfect for frozen waffles, bread, and breakfast treats; however, it's usually an uncooked waffle that's toasty on the outside but cold inside or defrosted but very watery. The aim is to find an appliance that can effectively defrost.

Is the toaster too big?

The kitchen counter is still valuable real property, even if you're not in a tiny space. With this in mind, we chose toasters that appeared carefully designed and balanced.

Are the settings easy to operate?

User-friendliness was a major concern for us. While we love the options available, we dislike design chaos. When we looked at each toaster, we assessed whether the toaster's control was functional and complete. We also assessed whether the interface appeared easy to understand (good) or required a careful review of the instruction manual (bad).

Do the customers love it?

It is important that we choose toasters to recommend that customers already love because those are the ones that are going to be the most successful. If a customer is unhappy with their purchase, the toaster will only end up in the landfill shortly after. Plus, it's a waste of money. We want to make sure that customers are happy with their purchase, and recommending a product that people are not going to like is not going to help us achieve that goal.

Buyer's Guide For Best Toaster Under $50

There is no need for a commercially-produced toaster to get evenly toasty bread. Low-cost appliances, like coffee makers as well as toasters, are also a great choice for people with low incomes. However, a toaster for less than $50 is sufficient for your needs. To ensure you get the highest quality at that cost, you must consider the following factors to take into consideration. Learn more about them in our buyer's guide that follows.


We've seen kitchen appliances that remain strong and durable for a long time. Toasters less than $50 are extremely durable if the ones you buy are constructed from high-quality materials. The stainless steel used in kitchen appliances can outlast plastic if used properly and properly maintained.

Before buying a toaster for less than $50, look at the components. Do they break easily? Do they withstand the rigors of frequent use? In addition, you should always opt for reputable brands.

Features Like Removable Crumb Tray

If you don't understand what to do in order to defrost your bread correctly? Wouldn't your toaster, less than $50 be able to toast and defrost it properly for you? This, along with other options like bagels as well as automatic shut-off and cancel settings, are some of the features to look to find when looking for a toaster that costs less than $50. These may be expensive; however, they will simplify your life.

Easy to clean

A dirty and unsanitary toaster. Even if cleaning is difficult, it may be a real hassle. Make sure that the toaster priced under $50 that you're about to buy won't cause anxiety when it's time to be scrubbed. We suggest you look for one that has removable crumb trays, parts, and even a dishwasher.


The exterior used in toasters' exteriors is more focused on aesthetics than any other aspect. Our tests observed that the quality of the toast was not damaged in any way.

  • Toasters made of plastic: Generally, plastic toasters tend to be more affordable than steel, but they're not always the most attractive.
  • Toasters made of metal: Metal toasters usually are stainless or brushed steel. They can be paired with other kitchen appliances.

Toaster's Design

When choosing a toaster to use, consider the amount of toast you usually create at once and the size of bread you prefer to toast.

  • Toasters with four slices: If more than two people are trying to cook breakfast simultaneously, the four-slice toaster is likely to be the best option.
  • Toasters with two slices: If counter space is a problem, you might prefer two-slice toasters.
  • Toasters with long slots: Long-slot toasters are gaining popularity due to the popularity of more traditional bread. Consider long slots if you are a fan of the artisanal bread of sourdough and other varieties. It's unlikely that you'll be able to fit a full slice in a standard toaster without cutting the bread in half.
  • Toasters with wide slots: Look out for toasters that have wide slots. They make toasting bagels or more substantial slices of bread a lot easy and hassle-free.


As well Toast your bread until it's to your preferred shade and degree of doneness; search for a toaster with the most suitable settings for you.

For instance, the bagel setting typically toasts only the interior of a bagel. It also warms the outside, so you don't have to fret about a dry or sour bite.

Defrost settings are great for frozen waffles and bread and will generally prolong the toasting process to ensure that you'll get the same results as you would have if the bread or waffles were fresh.

Reheat settings generally toast bread or other ingredients for a brief time, which is ideal for toasting a pastry in a toaster or adding a little color.

Additional Features

While not all toasters include extra features, some desirable features are worth looking for when choosing the right toaster.

  • The touchscreen user interface is simple to use and read with a stylish design and typically greater toasting choices.
  • The glass windows let you observe your toaster while it's toasting to decrease the chance of burned toast.
  • A high-lift or motorized lever helps solve the problem of stuck toast and is difficult to remove from the slot in the toaster, and it also eliminates the manual effort of pushing the lever down.

Toasters Under $50 Frequently Asked Questions

People are often intimidated by toasters that cost more than $50. They don't know if they're getting a good deal or not.

It can be tough to know which toaster is the best for you. Do you need one with all the bells and whistles, or will a basic model do the trick?

We've compiled a list of the most frequently asked questions about toasters under $50 so that you can make an informed decision before you buy. Whether you're looking for a 2-slice or 4-slice model, we have you covered.

What is the best toaster for under $50?

For less than $50, you can buy a toaster with standard features, such as multiple browning levels and a cancel button. Some toasters also have additional features, such as the ability to defrost bread or bagels and a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning.

To name a few quality, affordable toasters: Cuisinart toasters are a great option, same with Black+Decker, and Hamilton.

Which is better, a two slice or 4-slice toaster?

A two-slice toaster is better for those who have a small kitchen because it doesn't take up a lot of counter space. It's also good for people who don't need to toast a lot of bread at once. A four-slice toaster is better for those who have a large family or like to toast their bread in bulk.

How much should I spend on a toaster?

It depends on what you need. A cheap toaster will do the job, but it might not last as long as a more expensive model. If you want a toaster that has extra features, like a bagel or defrosts modes, you'll pay more. But in general, you should expect to spend around $30-$50 on a good toaster.

How long should a toaster last?

There is no specific answer to this question as it depends on a number of factors, such as the quality of the toaster and how often it is used. However, a high-quality toaster should last at least five years if used regularly.

Is a higher-wattage toaster better?

A higher-wattage toaster is better because it will heat up your bread faster and more evenly. This means that you'll avoid underdone toast and get toast consistently browned all the way across instead of having one side that's burnt to a crisp while the other is still pale.

Higher-wattage toasters also tend to have more features, such as wide slots for toasting bagels, English muffins or a defrost setting for frozen bread. So if you're looking for a high-quality toaster that can do it all, a model with a higher wattage is the way to go.

Final Remarks

Now that we've reviewed the best toasters under $50, we can tell you there really is no "best" toaster. Each toaster has unique strengths and weaknesses, which we've outlined in the individual reviews.

In our opinion, the best toaster under $50 is the Black + Decker. It has a sleek, elegant design that makes it the perfect addition to any kitchen. It is also versatile, with a bagel and frozen setting. The Black + Decker is also easy to use, with a lever to control the toasting process. This toaster is reliable, effective, and affordable, making it one of the best under $50. Which one is your favorite?

Items reviewed:

1. BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster

2. Mueller UltraToast Full Stainless Steel Toaster

3. Hamilton Beach Toaster Extra Wide Slots

4. iSiLER 2 Slice Toaster

5. Cuisinart Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster

6. BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

Casa Catalog is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to